Summary of “Marge Simpson, Blue-Haired
Housewife: Defining Domesticity on The Simpsons”
The main topic of “Marge Simpson,
Blue-Haired Housewife: Defining Domesticity on The Simpsons” written by
Jessamyn Neuhaus is that The Simpsons satirizes
the traditional family sitcoms like Father
Knows Best in which the images of father and mother are idealized, and being
a TV homemaker without frustration and exhaustion is unrealistic, but the core
value of the show is that man and woman should take their social roles
traditionally. There are three key terms in the essay: The Simpsons is “a direct challenge to the authoritative and
attentive fathers” and a various satire of “ideal American family and work life
on 1950s sitcoms” as well as the American dream, arousing viewers to notice
what they ignore in daily life; the endings of the show are always sentimental,
still affirming the core value of a “nuclear family”; Marge’s role of being an
“unconventional” homemaker, but she is still a fundamentally domestic role
embodying the core value of a “nuclear family.”
The first term Neuhas indicates that
in The Simpsons, the character of the
father and husband – Homer overthrows the impression of knowledgeable and
authoritative fathers made in 1950s sitcoms. Additionally, the show satirizes
the ideal American family and work life that idealized in 1950s as well as the
American dream from many aspects. For example, Neuhas lists detail examples
from education – “The teachers in Springfield are bored and quick to stifle any
creativity or curiosity in their pupils,” as well as religion – “The town’s
leading Christiana are annoying…” The show also aims to invite viewers to
notice what they ignore in the daily life. Neuhas quotes from Philip Roth,
“Satire is mortal outrage transformed into comic art.”
In the second term, Neuhas concludes
that although the show satirizes many American social stereotypes, the endings
of the show are always sentimental and touching, which affirms the core values
of “a solid nuclear family,” such as loyalty, love, affection and Christianity.
Neuhas explains that “despite their (the Simpsons) arguments, conflicts, and
even physical violence toward one another,” the children often “express their
affection for and loyalty to their parents” and “the Simpsons family is the
only sitcom family to regularly attend church and to frequently dis cuss God
and faith.”
As for the third term, the
discussion of Marge’s role in the family and the small society of the
Springfield is the most important part of the essay. Firstly, Neuhas asserts
that Marge’s role satirizes the myth of the ideal TV housewife by not easily
resolving the frustration and exhaustion from bunches of housework. She lists
three ways that Marge used to use to “dislocate herself from her domestic role
fail” but they all didn’t work well. The first is to have a “two-star” spa, but
the relief is temporary. The second one is to be employed and doing volunteer
work outside home, but it is not a lasting solution. The third one is to
procure her self-fulfillment via her strength, - a bake-off outside home, but
she failed either. Therefore, finding values besides domestic roles is hard for
homemakers, and Marge’s experiences question and refute the stereotype of being
an ideal homemaker is always content. The second term that Neuhas points out is
that as a homemaker, Marge’s participation in politics not only emphasizes the
political stances of its authors, but also “demonstrates the way women have
expanded their domestic sphere to include a public, political role.” Neuhas
takes the letters between Ms. Bush and Marge as an example, indicating Marge’s
good ability in participating and holding various political events, and she
also represents the homemakers who also attended in public and political
events. The third term is that “Marge is still a fundamentally domestic character”
and the show still expresses the idea of the traditional social gender roles
that “women’s place is in the home.” Neuhas lists the examples from different
episodes that whenever Marge leaves the family, the family would be in a mess.
On the other hand, Marge likes being a homemaker herself, because however Homer
becomes, she still think he is a “perfect” man. Therefore, from the “sporadic
satire of ‘housewife’ character, and only partial critiques of domestic gender
roles; conflicts that are always resolved when Marge returns to homemaking.”
In conclusion, Neuhas mainly argues that The Simpsons satirizes the traditional
family sitcoms like Father Knows Best
in which the images of father and mother are idealized, the endings of the show
still expresses what the sitcoms in 1950s want to express, and being a TV
homemaker without frustration and exhaustion is unrealistic, but the core value
of the show is that man and woman should take their social roles as in “nuclear
families.”